Case number: 2:20-bk-05008 - The Bay Club of Naples, LLC and The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC - Florida Middle Bankruptcy Court

Case Information
  • Case title

    The Bay Club of Naples, LLC and The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC

  • Court

    Florida Middle (flmbke)

  • Chapter

    11

  • Judge

    Caryl E. Delano

  • Filed

    06/29/2020

  • Last Filing

    04/28/2026

  • Asset

    Yes

  • Vol

    v

Docket Header
ADV, PriorCase, MEDIAT, CONFIRMED, JNTADMN, LEAD, MotDismissPend, APPEAL



U.S. Bankruptcy Court
Middle District of Florida (Ft. Myers)
Bankruptcy Petition #: 2:20-bk-05008-FMD

Assigned to: Caryl E. Delano
Chapter 11
Voluntary
Asset


Date filed:  06/29/2020
Plan confirmed:  06/16/2021
341 meeting:  09/03/2020
Deadline for filing claims:  09/08/2020

Debtor

The Bay Club of Naples, LLC

1165 8th St S
Naples, FL 34102
COLLIER-FL
Tax ID / EIN: 47-3831677

represented by
Paul J Battista

Venable LLP
801 Brickell Avenue, Suite 1500
Miami, FL 33131
305-349-2300
Email: pjbattista@venable.com

Adam M Gilbert

Underwood Murray, P.A.
100 North Tampa Street, Suite 2325
Tampa, FL 33602
813-540-8404
Email: agilbert@underwoodmurray.com

Eric D Jacobs

Venable LLP
100 N. Tampa Street
Suite 2600
Tampa, FL 33602
813-439-3100
Email: edjacobs@venable.com

Megan Wilson Murray

Underwood Murray, P.A.
100 N. Tampa Avenue
Suite 2325
Tampa, FL 33602
813-540-8403
Email: mmurray@underwoodmurray.com

Jon Polenberg

Becker & Poliakoff, P.A.
1 East Broward Blvd., Suite 1800
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
954-364-6037
Fax : 954-985-4176
Email: jpolenberg@beckerlawyers.com

Melissa J Sydow

Underwood Murray, P.A.
100 North Tampa Street, Suite 2325
Tampa, FL 33602
813-540-8406
Email: msydow@underwoodmurray.com

Scott A Underwood

Underwood Murray, P.A.
100 North Tampa St, Suite 2325
Tampa, FL 33602
813-540-8402
Fax : 813-553-5345
Email: sunderwood@underwoodmurray.com

C. B. Upton

The Upton Law Firm
1400 Village Square Boulevard
Suite 3-276
Tallahassee, FL 32312
850-792-5291

Debtor In Possession

The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC

1165 8th St S
Naples, FL 32102
COLLIER-FL
Tax ID / EIN: 47-3831677

represented by
Paul J Battista

(See above for address)

Adam M Gilbert

(See above for address)

Eric D Jacobs

(See above for address)

Megan Wilson Murray

(See above for address)

Jon Polenberg

(See above for address)

Melissa J Sydow

(See above for address)

Scott A Underwood

(See above for address)

C. B. Upton

(See above for address)

U.S. Trustee

United States Trustee - FTM

Timberlake Annex, Suite 1200
501 E. Polk Street
Tampa, FL 33602
813-228-2000
represented by
Benjamin E. Lambers

Timberlake Annex
501 E. Polk Street, Suite 1200
Tampa, FL 33602
813-228-2000
Email: Ben.E.Lambers@usdoj.gov

Nathan A Wheatley

DOJ-Ust
200 N. High St.
Ste 309
Columbus, OH 43215
614-469-7446
Email: nathan.a.wheatley@usdoj.gov

Latest Dockets

Date Filed#Docket Text
04/28/2026960Motion to Determine Amount and Extent of Attorneys' Fees and Costs Filed by Scott A Underwood on behalf of Interested Parties The Nautilus Naples, LLC, The Viceroy of Naples, LLC (related document(s)[942]). (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit Exhibit A Underwood Murray Spreadsheet # (2) Exhibit Exhibit B- User Initial Legend # (3) Exhibit Exhibit C-Underwood Murray Cost Spreadsheet.pdf # (4) Exhibit Exhibit D- YP Spreadsheet)
04/27/2026959Chapter 11 Post-Confirmation Report for Case Number 20-05009 for the Quarter Ending: 12/31/2025 Filed by Scott A Underwood on behalf of Debtor In Possession The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC, Debtor The Bay Club of Naples, LLC. (Underwood, Scott)
04/27/2026958Chapter 11 Post-Confirmation Report for the Quarter Ending: 12/31/2025 Filed by Scott A Underwood on behalf of Debtor In Possession The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC, Debtor The Bay Club of Naples, LLC. (Underwood, Scott)
04/27/2026957Chapter 11 Monthly Operating Report for Case Number 20-05009 for the Month Ending: 03/31/2026 Filed by Scott A Underwood on behalf of Debtor In Possession The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC. (Underwood, Scott)
04/27/2026956Chapter 11 Monthly Operating Report for the Month Ending: 03/31/2026 Filed by Scott A Underwood on behalf of Debtor In Possession The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC, Debtor The Bay Club of Naples, LLC. (Underwood, Scott)
04/21/2026955Transmittal of Record on Appeal to District Court. Case No. 2:25-cv-568-JES-NPM and 2-25-cv-570-JES-NPM (related document(s)903, 902). (Anel) (Entered: 04/24/2026)
04/15/2026954
Hearing Proceeding Memo: Hearing Held -
APPEARANCES:
APPEARANCES Nathan Wheatley, Mark Wolfson, Scott Shuker, Melissa Sydow, Scott Underwood
RULING:
Continued Status Conference/Case Status -
Concluded.
Proposed Orders, if applicable, should be submitted within three days after the date of the hearing - Local Rule 9072-1(c).
This docket entry/document is not an official order of the Court
. (Bill) (Entered: 04/16/2026)
04/13/2026953Appellees' Designation of Contents for Inclusion in Record of Appeal Filed by Scott A Underwood on behalf of Debtor In Possession The Bay Club of Naples I, LLC, Debtor The Bay Club of Naples II, LLC, Interested Party The Nautilus Naples, LLC, and Sachem Capital Corp. (Underwood, Scott). Related document(s) 903, 908, 910. Modified on 4/15/2026 (LC). (Entered: 04/13/2026)
04/12/2026952BNC Certificate of Mailing - Notice of Hearing (related document(s) (Related Doc [951])). Notice Date 04/12/2026. (Admin.)
04/10/2026951Notice Rescheduling Status Conference (as to time only). Hearing scheduled for 4/15/2026 at 11:30 AM at Ft. Myers, FL - Room 4-102, Hearing Room, United States Courthouse, 2110 First Street, Ft. Myers, FL. (Dello Iacono, Ann)